Over & Underrated discs?

[Paintball1084]

under rated: Gateway warrior

over rated: VP (yeah I went there)

OH NO U dI INT

over: Xcal??
under: star beast??

[Timko]

Overrated: Throwing what Blake tells you to
Underrated: Throwing what works for you

*Customized for these boards.

this is funny.

[Gilligan]

Overrated: ROCs Yeah, I said it... the Buzzz is better and I don't even throw one! I mean, unless it's a rancho roc molded on a tuesday in spring with a north wind blowing (really do they need that many variations?!) Also the teebird... I don't disagree it's a nice disc but slow down on the love on that thing (especially the 8x,9x, CE blah blah)... for that matter any "CE" version of a disc.

Underrated... simple, Cobra! (in all plastics!) and the Drone (THANK YOU for making it in FLX!) And the Crow.


*edit... now what!

[Booter]

sweet. I never new there was a ranchero mold!!! I'll have to add it to my stack!.

[Ryan C]

Am I the only one who doesn't think the Boss is overrated? I use them all the time to great result. And they go farther than my orcs by a good 25 feet consistently.

I'd say:

Overrated: The Nuke, since its basically a Boss, but apparently is cool on DGR to like.
Underrated: Since everyone seems to hate it, I'd say....The Boss.

[money 21]

overrated the comet. I have had several and don't like them.
underrated the element it flies like what everyone tells me the comet should.

[marmoset]

overrated the comet. I have had several and don't like them.

Ha!
DGR is the only place the Comet could possibly be considered for the overrated category.

[Tossin' in Memphis]

sweet. I never new there was a ranchero mold!!! I'll have to add it to my stack!.

The ranchero Roc comes with hash browns, cheese and onions...I think...

[Booter]

sweet. I never new there was a ranchero mold!!! I'll have to add it to my stack!.

The ranchero Roc comes with hash browns, cheese and onions...I think...

mmmm I'll have to pick some up now.

[StumperTX]

Am I the only one who doesn't think the Boss is overrated? I use them all the time to great result. And they go farther than my orcs by a good 25 feet consistently.

I'd say:

Overrated: The Nuke, since its basically a Boss, but apparently is cool on DGR to like.
Underrated: Since everyone seems to hate it, I'd say....The Boss.

I agree that the Boss is tremendously underrated on this board (judging by all of the Boss overrated early posts). the thing is stoopid long, and if you find the right one, literally impossible to flip (I apparently have one).

But man I don't think the Nuke bears any resemblance to the Boss. The Boss is so much more (over)stable in comparison.

[Frank Delicious]

overrated the comet. I have had several and don't like them.
underrated the element it flies like what everyone tells me the comet should.

What comets do you have and what are you looking for?

[KJDog19]

Over: Roc...yup, I said it. (Decent mid that is versatile, but it does not excel at anything that another mid couldn't do better.)

Under: Lids (Polecat, Putt'r, Birdie, etc.)

[Booter]

yea I agree...1 of the best selling mids in discgolf is severely overrated

[Jeronimo]

yea I agree...1 of the best selling mids in discgolf is severely overrated

I'm glad you agree! You've had your eyes opened.

[veganray]

Over = Wizard
Under = Viking