Hello to everybody, and Peace!
First I want to thank you Mr Iacas for your research and efforts with this project. Keep going.
This is a project that needs the judge, leader or however you name him. He will make a logical conclusion from all the data we will provide him. That is not anything dramatic. If the judge rejects some information he is given to without close study, he will lose the recpect from us and this thread will die. After that somebody else will, hopefully, continue this interesting research.
At the moment I trust Iacas is striving honestly for an unbiased list based on facts.
Beside that, Iacas, in the following example you "forgot" to mention you don't have the final
list. Thus you asked for more troubles and we others had to read still more debate. Some people can read between lines what is your actual meaning but that is not self evident, as you see.
JR wrote:You have already made mistakes in the keys list
iacas wrote:I don't even have a Keys list!?!
To have a preliminary plan or model is normal process when resarching. Further studies and open-minded discussion will guide it to some direction.
Now, let's go to an actual case concerning the research on the Simple Keys list:
Someone, (there might be some others beside JR), tells that after the first steps you have to push with your left foot (rhbh) when throwing or before throwing. Now. what the the judge will do? He will go and find 20 other pro players, who can confirm that without pushing he will lose distance. In addition the judge will check if he is able to find DG instructors from youtube who are teaching: foot push, hips, shoulders and so on. If the judge is not able to have these findings, he can not but reject the foot push theory as being unreliable. That is part of his work. He just have to proceed that way.
I have got some positive words about the work JR has been doing, of cource, but on an other time.