PMantle wrote:Star Shark wrote:I am a little confused here, also. I'm not sure how 13 could be good and 9 isn't. Both miss one of the two mandos on the 2nd shot. 14 is obviously missed on the first shot and should go to a dz. 12 and 11 are both properly played.
9 would be fine if there were only one mando. Throw 2 misses the right mando.
Right, but both do that. How can one of them be good and not the other? I understand that some of what is being said here indicates that once you've properly made a mando, it ceases to exist. If that's the case, both of them should be legal. However, if you still have to make the mando on the the second shot, neither example should be valid.